Business / Provisional alcohol licences granted for new Co-op stores
Concern had been expressed by NHS Shetland over whether there could be overprovision of off sales in the Scalloway and Sandwick areas
PROVISIONAL alcohol licences have been granted for two new Co-op stores in Scalloway and Sandwick – despite concern from NHS Shetland about potential overprovision in the villages.
Meanwhile the stores are now expected to open in late 2023 or perhaps early in 2024.
Shetland’s licensing board granted the seven day a week, 10am to 10pm provisional licences at a meeting on Monday morning.
Applications for full premises licences would then follow.
But NHS Shetland had responded to the licence applications by saying they would represent a “huge increase” in the availability of off sales alcohol in the areas.
“Off-sales alcohol are known to be more harmful than on-sales because the alcohol is then consumed in an unregulated environment,” the representation added.
However representative for national retailer Co-op Eilidh McGuire said alcohol would only account for around 12 per cent of sales space in the Sandwick store, for instance.
And she said the idea of reducing the capacity of alcohol being sold would probably not affect sales and would only lead to more regular restocking.
The health board also raised concern abut the having the alcohol aisle and the beer, wine and spirits promotions close to the checkouts, adding that it is “not good practice for people who are dependent on or seeking to reduce their alcohol consumption”.
It suggested a first step would be to reduce the quantity of alcohol being sold, re-consider the placement of the products and think about the support that will be offered to people who are struggling with alcohol use.
Finally, the health board said it would appreciate the licensing board giving consideration as to whether it would create overprovision in Scalloway and Sandwick.
The two stores, which would be similar in size to the Brae Co-op, have already attracted controversy from some in the local industry and community over their potential impact on existing businesses.
Monday’s meeting heard the investment per store would be around £1.5 million, with 15 jobs in line to be created at each.
They would be located at East Voe in Scalloway and Stove in Sandwick, with both similar sizes. Construction is not yet underway.
Councillors said they had sympathy for the health board’s views, but were minded to approve the applications.
SIC solicitor Paul Wishart said there was deemed to be no overprovision at the moment in Shetland.
Overprovision could potentially cover Shetland as a whole, or “it could be a street in Lerwick”, he said for example.
McGuire told Monday’s meeting that the placement of alcohol in Co-op stores was something which has been “carefully considered” for years.
But she said having alcohol at the back of store does not provide the “benefits” that is hoped.
Instead, she said having alcohol closer to tills can increase monitoring and also the promotion of licensing objectives.
McGuire added that the Co-op wants the new Shetland outlets to be “well run” stores.
Shetland North councillor Tom Morton, meanwhile mentioned how some alcohol is kept behind counters in the Brae Co-op – items which may be more likely to be the subject of theft or which are most “in demand”, like Buckfast and half bottles of spirits.
McGuire confirmed that this was a Co-op policy and one that would be replicated in the new shops.
During debate council leader Emma Macdonald said she had sympathy with NHS Shetland’s views.
She said she had concerns about having “more easily accessible alcohol in a period of time when people might be finding life more difficult”.
But she said she appreciated the responses from the Co-op representative.
Lerwick North and Bressay member Stephen Leask added that he felt alcohol sold behind counters should also be blanked out, like how cigarettes are.
And Morton added that ordering alcohol online is potentially a bigger problem – saying it happens “blind”.
Councillors also noted that there are more alcohol licences in the Scalloway and Burra area compared to Sandwick.
But they did not raise the idea of overprovision and approved the two provisional licences.
Become a member of Shetland News
Shetland News is asking its many readers to consider paying for membership to get additional features and services: -
- Remove non-local ads;
- Bookmark posts to read later;
- Exclusive curated weekly newsletter;
- Hide membership messages;
- Comments open for discussion.
If you appreciate what we do and feel strongly about impartial local journalism, then please become a member of Shetland News by either making a single payment, or setting up a monthly, quarterly or yearly subscription.
Already a member? Sign in to hide this message.
