Letters / Still time to set this right
Open letter to: Council leader Cecil Smith, Convener Malcolm Bell, the Education and Family committee, and all elected members.
Last week’s Shetland Times article with Barbara Rosie was brilliant, and a fantastic prelude to the hostel reunion, which takes place this month. However, when reading the words “Anderson High School Halls of Residence”, it was a reminder that this is still the current proposed name for the new building.
The Education and Families committee seemed mainly concerned about the idea of “setting a precedent” in naming the building after a public servant who is still alive.
This precedent was set some time ago, e.g. the Hendra, Edward Thomason House etc, each named after a deserving (and living) retired public servant who devoted a good chunk of their life to our community. George McGhee is unquestionably one of our most well-respected and hardworking public servants, and there is clearly a great deal of support for honouring him in this way:
- A spontaneous online petition set up well before the Education and Families decision, supporting “The George McGhee Halls”, attracted over 700 signatures.
- The results of the SIC’s consultation on the hostel name overwhelmingly echoed that it should be the “George McGhee Halls”.
- A Facebook petition launched soon after the Education and Families decision, entitled “Not the AHS Halls”, and supporting the “George McGhee” option, attracted several hundred “likes”, “shares” and “signatures”.
- A very well-written letter appeared in the Shetland News last year after the decision, which summed-up public opinion at the time and was signed by a large number of people. It’s well worth a read, and can be found at: www.shetnews.co.uk/letters/13391-insulting-consulting
Whilst last year’s committee decision ran contrary to the voices of hostel residents present and past, there is still time to set this right, as the building’s “official” opening ceremony is not due to take place until next year. We urge you to take another look at this, in light of the strength of feeling on this issue.
Peter Gear
Bell Road, Lerwick
Debbie Jamieson
Kim Anderson
Aaron Smith
Agnes Jayne Smith
Alana Henry
Alex Hutchison
Alison Eunson
Amanda Gray
Ann Thomson
Anne Brown
Calum Burgess
Charlotte Beattie
Cheyenne Blair-Walker
Chloe Miller
Chris Coles
Christine Sinclair
Claire Morris
Colin Dickie
Daniel Aqualina
Daniel Gear
David Pattinson
David Thompson
Davy Shearer
Debbie Murray
Dione Paul
Elke Mchale-Smith
Elspeth Manson
Emma Nisbet
Gary Andrew Mouat
Hannah Ruth Sawford
Ingrid Pottinger
Jack Jamieson
Jan Sawford
Jenna Thomason
Jim Quinn
Jim Tait
Joe Finnie
Jolene Tindall
Kair Hamilton
Karen Wood
Kerri Eunson
Kieran Wilbourne
Laura Hodge
Laura Lyth
Laura Polson
Lauren Brewster
Lauren Kelsey
Layla Sawford
Leona Gear
Lisa Jamieson
Loanna Leishman
Lorna Leask
Louise Sales
Lyall Campbell
Lynda Hutchison
Mairi Polson
Margaret Gear
Marie Manson
Marlyn Watt
Mary Hill
Mary Watt
Mathew Roberts
Matthew Laurenson
Matthew Saunders
Megan Burns
Megan Nisbet
Melanie Mouat
Michelle Stove
Neil Anderson
Nicky Henderson
Nicola Polson
Paul Mullen
Peter Arthur
Rachael Boxall
Richard Gibson
Richie Hutchison
Robert Gray
Ronald Poleson
Rose Young
Ross Thomson
Sara Fox
Sharon Mullen
Stewart Abernethy
Stuart Cameron
Sue Beer
Valerie Sales
Victoria Anderson
Become a member of Shetland News
Shetland News is asking its many readers to consider paying for membership to get additional features and services: -
- Remove non-local ads;
- Bookmark posts to read later;
- Exclusive curated weekly newsletter;
- Hide membership messages;
- Comments open for discussion.
If you appreciate what we do and feel strongly about impartial local journalism, then please become a member of Shetland News by either making a single payment, or setting up a monthly, quarterly or yearly subscription.
Already a member? Sign in to hide this message.
